Contributing Author/s

Rev. Dr. Paris L. Smith, Sr.
What Black Protest Music Teaches Us to Hear
What Black Protest Music Teaches Us to Hear
Motown was the backdrop to my upbringing in Detroit, but the music that raised me reached beyond any one label. As a Black child, a Black boy, a Black teenager, and a Black young adult in America, I kept hearing more in voices I already knew. Nina Simone and Marvin Gaye are two of those voices. I hear their songs differently now because I pay closer attention to the trouble they were answering. A song can stay on the radio long after listeners have stopped asking what made its words necessary.
These songs help me un-fragment the struggle by bringing parts of Black life into view together. In Simone, the demand for equality runs through everyday labor and the fight over school desegregation. In Gaye, family grief leads us to the picket line. Black identity, Black power, and Black empowerment come into focus through those connections. People claim the authority to describe the lives they are living, challenge the people whose decisions shape those lives, and begin to see what they might do together.
Who Can Afford to Wait
In June 1963, Medgar Evers was murdered in Mississippi. In September, a bomb at Birmingham’s Sixteenth Street Baptist Church killed four Black girls. The Library of Congress places both attacks in the history of “Mississippi Goddam.” Historian Nadine Cohodas dates Simone’s composition to the immediate aftermath of the bombing. The recording followed in 1964. Simone was writing while the country was still being asked to reckon with those deaths. [1] [2]
Early in the song, Simone names Alabama, Tennessee, and Mississippi. The names come quickly, and each place makes the next harder to hear as an isolated case. Simone puts her own fear into the song. Her fear becomes a judgment about the conditions people are living in. I hear her claiming the authority to say what those conditions are like from inside them. A listener who expects her to explain why she is angry has to reckon first with the places she is naming.
Later, Simone turns the instruction to “go slow” into a recurring response. She brings window washing and cotton picking into the same passage as desegregation, and she invokes the accusation of laziness. I hear a double standard. The people who judge Black workers for their supposed slowness can ask those same workers to wait for equality. The brisk performance makes the instruction sound all the more absurd. When those who benefit from delay control the calendar, a promise of change can help keep the old arrangements in place. [3] [7]
Near the end, Simone puts equality in the first person and brings her people into the claim. The sequence matters. A woman who has named her own fear can speak publicly about what she and others are owed. As a Baptist preacher, I hear that as prophetic speech. She calls the people who ask for patience to account for what their timetable costs the people expected to live by it.
Who Belongs at the Picket Line
“What’s Going On,” released in 1971, began with Renaldo “Obie” Benson’s account of witnessing police violence against protesters in Berkeley during the 1969 People’s Park conflict. Benson shares the writing credit with Al Cleveland and Marvin Gaye. The Vietnam War is also part of the record’s context. Gaye’s brother Frankie served there, and the Library of Congress essay connects his experience of coming home to the album’s next track, “What’s Happening Brother.” The title song itself puts an appeal against war and a plea against brutality within hearing of one another. [4] [5]
Gaye addresses a mother, then brothers, then a father. He moves from weeping to dying to a plea against escalation. At the picket line, the person who asks to be heard speaks as “me” and addresses someone who can respond as “you.” I hear that singular voice as part of a collective claim. The people whose grief we have been asked to hear can also speak for themselves, and the lyric gives the listener a place in that exchange. [4] [5] [6]
Gaye asks for conversation in the same passage in which he asks for an end to brutality. That pairing puts a condition on the conversation. A person has to be able to speak without being struck down for speaking. I hear the earlier appeal to family carrying into that demand. If the listener has already been drawn close enough to hear the mourning, how will that listener respond when the people on the picket line ask to be heard on their own terms?
What the Songs Bring Together
Simone makes delay itself part of the injustice. Gaye makes the treatment of protesters part of what the public must answer for. Put the songs together and a question comes into focus. Who gets to decide when Black people may press their claims, and what happens when they press them anyway? That is where I hear identity, power, and empowerment meet. People speak from their own lives, challenge the terms on which they are heard, and recognize a claim they can make together. The decisions about how to organize and what to demand belong to the people living through the trouble.
When I return to the music I grew up with in Detroit, I hear the voices that helped me know who I was. I also hear what those voices were asking of the people around them. When someone tells a community to be patient, I want to know who owns the calendar. When people take to the street, I want to know what they have already tried to say and who finally has to hear it.
Sources
1. National Recording Registry, “Mississippi Goddam”
2. Nadine Cohodas, “Mississippi Goddam,” Library of Congress
3. Nina Simone, “Mississippi Goddam,” official live audio
4. Library of Congress, “What’s Going On”
5. Make Public, “What’s Going On,” song history and writing credits
6. Marvin Gaye, “What’s Going On,” original recording
7. Nina Simone official discography, “Mississippi Goddam,” lyrics
Disclaimer:
Article Tags
Related Title/s
Contributing Author/s



